Most marks in a venture portfolio were set on the day of a round. The company raised, the price was known, the fund wrote it down.
Then the quarters went by.
Rounds are when the price is clear
A priced round is the one moment when a private company's value is reasonably clear. Between rounds, the fund has to estimate.
For a lot of small funds, the easiest estimate is to leave the last price where it is. Nothing new has been priced, so nothing changes in the report. But the company keeps moving. It hits a milestone, misses one, loses a key hire, lands a big customer. The mark stays where it was.
There isn't one right method
It would be easier if there were a single accepted way to revisit a mark. There isn't.
Seth Levine of Foundry wrote in Valuation Policies Are A Mess that when he helped a fund with its valuation policy, they asked several of its LPs for a "best-in-class" valuation policy. "No one could come up with one." Under the ASC 820 standard, he notes, "there doesn't seem to be one."
He also describes "surprising divergences between how the same asset was reported from one fund to another", depending on the method, the inputs and the audit firm.
So the same company can sit at one value in your report and a different one in a co-investor's.
Rigour added, and judgement too
Fair-value rules were meant to make fund reporting more rigorous. Levine's view is that they also introduced "even more variability and subjectivity into the process."
None of that means funds are careless. Most do their best with what they have. But it does mean a mark is only as good as the information behind it at the time it was set, and how recently someone looked again.
The question an LP might ask
An LP reading your report may never ask how a mark was set. They might ask something simpler: what's happened at this company since the last time it changed?
It might be worth checking, before the next report goes out, whether you could answer that for every company in the portfolio. Which marks have the latest news sitting right next to them, and which ones were last looked at when the round closed?
◆ ◆ ◆
Quantro for funds keeps every portfolio company on one page, with structured updates, return metrics and documents arriving as founders publish them, so the news behind a number is never far from it.
Frequently asked questions
What is a stale mark?
A stale mark is a valuation that hasn't been revisited since it was set, usually at the company's last funding round, and may no longer reflect how the company is doing.
Is there a standard way for venture funds to value holdings?
Venture funds report fair value under ASC 820, but the standard allows several accepted methods. Seth Levine of Foundry has written that when a fund asked its LPs for a best-in-class valuation policy, no one could come up with one.
Why can two funds value the same company differently?
Each fund picks its own method and inputs, and its audit firm signs off on its own terms. That can produce different values for the same holding in two funds' reports.